Over at his
Puppetminister Blog last week,
Ben talked about
the problem with Christian puppetry. Here's my favourite excerpt:
"...there is no excuse for sloppy manipulation. The concepts are simple and good execution takes practice. Am I the best in the world? No. Do I practice enough? No., but Jesus died for me, the least I can do is develop good puppetry skills..."
There's a long and proud connection between puppetry and religion, but most Christian puppetry isn't just bad, it's painful (check out
this if you don't believe me). The talent and potential for artistic expression is out there...great puppeteers and builders like
Dave Privett and
Steve Axtell do a fantastic of combining puppet entertainment and Christian ministry and Ben himself wrote an
ebook on the subject.
I think the real problem is an emphasis on ministry over artistry. Of course ministry is the first goal of Christian puppetry, but why can't there be top-notch artistry too? I don't mean to attack the well-intentioned, faithful people who simply put on puppet shows in Sunday School every week, but Christian puppeteers should challenge themselves to do better than the generic puppets and scripts that seem to dominate the genre.
That's what I think anyway.
--
09/10/06 Update: Puppets and Coffee has chimed in on the subject of Christian puppetry and provides an interesting, albeit totally agnostic view on the issue. I don't completely agree with all of it, but it does provide a similar take on the "ministry over artistry" approach I mentioned above.