
I'm really enjoying reading Spline Doctors, a new group blog by six of Pixar's animators but I have to take issue with one of their recent posts which I couldn't help but interpret as a bit of a dig at motion capture. What they seem to be implying is that conventional 3D animation is vastly superior (and often cheaper) than motion capture. Compare the characters in mocap movies like The Polar Express (creepy) and Final Fantasy (really, really creepy) to animated characters in movies like the Incredibles and you can't help but see their point.
Still, I don't believe mocap is without it's place. Conventional mocap with actors is great tool for visual effects artists and video game designers. When it comes to actually animating characters via mocap I think the best route is the one the Creature Shop has taken with projects like the upcoming Frances. Motion capture using a puppetry interface allows you to create animation in real-time that can be cleaned up and fine tuned in post. It's fast, flexible and (arguably) less time consuming.
Of course I'm not without my own bias and most puppeteers will always argue for puppetry and animators will always argue for animation. In the end I think it comes down to simply choosing which approach is right for the story you're trying to tell. The real truth is that creating quality 3D animation is difficult and expensive whichever way you do it.
No matter what side of this debate you're on there is one thing I think we can all agree on...they should have never, ever made Final Fantasy. Well, that and yeah, it is pretty cool that Dick Van Dyke is willing to strap on a lycra suit with reflective ping pong balls.